CA K Sanjay BhargavChartered Accountant
Open menu

Sell-to-cover RSUs: the tax sale you never saw, and why it still counts

CA K Sanjay Bhargav, Chartered Accountant, Bengaluru

Membership No. 250054 · DISA (ICAI)

Published

Short answer: under sell-to-cover, the full number of vested shares is credited to you, and some are sold, usually the next trading day, to pay the tax. On the better view those shares were yours, the sale was your transfer, and the small gain or loss on it belongs in Schedule CG. The vested lot, including the part sold, belongs in Schedule FA for that calendar year. Self-filed returns often leave the tax sales out. For FAST-DS, the shares go in Entry 2 for a flat ₹1 lakh. A year's net untaxed gain goes in Entry 1 at 60%. A year with only small losses, and no other untaxed foreign income, has no Entry 1 row. Under net settlement, the withheld shares were never yours, and none of this applies to them.

Two ways the tax gets paid

When RSUs vest, the vested value is salary, taxed as a perquisite under section 17(2)(vi) through your employer's payroll. The plan has to fund that tax, and it does so in one of two ways:

Net settlementSell-to-cover
What reaches your accountOnly the shares left after taxThe full number of vested shares
How the tax is fundedThe employer keeps back sharesThe broker sells some of your shares, usually the next trading day
Were the tax shares ever yours?NoYes, for a day or two
A capital gain on the tax shares?NoYes, usually small
In Schedule FA?Only the shares deliveredThe whole vested lot, with the sale

The contrary argument is that shares sold to cover tax were never really at your disposal, so they should be treated like withheld shares. Where the shares were credited to your account and the sale settled there, the better view is that they were held, and that is the safer basis for Schedule FA and FAST-DS.

How to tell which applies. The release confirmation for each vest lists the shares released, the shares withheld or sold to cover, and the shares deposited. A trade confirmation for a sale on the day after the vest, settling in your account, is sell-to-cover. Where there is no confirmation, the account statement shows it: under net settlement, the vest appears as a deposit of the net shares with no sale.

Some plans used one method for years and then switched, and a few use both: sell-to-cover for RSUs, and no tax sale at all for ESPP purchases, which are bought from post-tax pay. Check one release confirmation from each year.

What the tax sale looks like in rupees

Your cost for the shares is the value your employer took for the perquisite (section 49(2AA)): the plan's market value on the vest date, converted at the rate the employer used. The sale is converted, in the usual practice, on the date Rule 115 of the Income-tax Rules fixes for capital gains: the State Bank of India telegraphic transfer buying rate on the last day of the month before the month of sale. The two rates differ, so the rupee result can differ from the dollar one.

An illustration, with invented but realistic figures: 100 RSUs vest at a plan value of $150, converted by payroll at ₹83.00, so the perquisite is ₹12,45,000. The broker sells 36 shares to cover tax, usually within a day or a few days of the vest, with a $15 fee. The rupee cost of those 36 shares is 36 × $150 × ₹83.00 = ₹4,48,200.

Vest on 12 June, sold the next dayVest on 26 June, sold three trading days later, on 1 July
Sale price$148.50$149.70
Proceeds after the $15 fee$5,331.00$5,374.20
Rule 115 rate (last day of the previous month)₹83.20 (31 May)₹83.60 (30 June)
Proceeds in rupees₹4,43,539₹4,49,283
Short-term capital gain or (loss)(₹4,661)₹1,083
The same sale in dollars($69) loss($26) loss

In the second column the sale is a dollar loss but a rupee gain. The sale falls in July, so it is converted at the rate for 30 June, four days after the vest, and the rupee had weakened in between. The gap between the two rate sources matters too: payroll often uses the RBI reference rate, which usually sits above SBI's buying rate, and that pushes the result towards a loss. The illustration uses a payroll rate below both SBI rates to show the effect; real figures can go either way. Small sums, but a return that leaves them out is a return that did not disclose foreign-source income. These are short-term gains, because shares of a foreign company not listed in India are long-term only after 24 months. They are taxed at slab rates and go in Schedule CG with the details of each sale.

In Schedule FA

Schedule FA reports the calendar year ending in the financial year. A vest in June 2024 belongs in the return for AY 2025-26:

  • Table A3, the foreign equity holding: the vested lot, with the vest date as the acquisition date and the vest-date value as the initial value, then the peak value, the closing value and the gross proceeds from sale. That column exists because shares bought and sold within the year are reportable.
  • Table A2, the brokerage account: its peak and closing balance, and the gross amount credited to it. Where sale proceeds pass through the account, report the credits as sale proceeds, not as dividends.

A tax sale of shares that are then entirely gone still leaves the account open for that year. "There was nothing left at 31 December" is not a reason to leave a year blank.

The field-by-field mapping is in Schedule FA from your broker statement. Platform specifics are in Schedule FA for Fidelity, Schwab and Morgan Stanley.

The ₹20 lakh test

From 1 October 2024 the Black Money Act penalty and prosecution for not reporting a foreign asset do not apply where the aggregate value of the assets, other than immovable property, does not exceed ₹20 lakh. Whether that reaches returns filed before that date is arguable. CBDT's instruction of 18 August 2025 applies the prosecution test at any time during the relevant previous year, so it is a peak, not a year-end figure. See the ₹20 lakh threshold.

Sell-to-cover affects the peak in two ways:

  • On the vest day the account holds the whole vested lot, not just the shares you keep.
  • After the tax sale settles, the proceeds can sit in your account until they are passed on to the employer. For a day or two the account holds the retained shares plus that cash.

The opposite mistake inflates the peak: counting the shares sold and the cash from the same sale on the same day. Shares count up to the sale; cash counts from the day it settles. For an employee who sells everything within days of each vest, the peak usually stays well below ₹20 lakh. A large vest, or holding the shares for months, takes it up quickly.

The threshold is about assets. It does not cover foreign income left out of the return, and an unreported capital gain is foreign income.

In a FAST-DS declaration

ItemWhere it goesCost
The vested shares, including those sold to cover tax, left out of Schedule FAEntry 2: assets acquired from income offered to taxFlat ₹1 lakh for the whole declaration
A financial year's net capital gain from foreign shares, never offered, up to FY 2024-25Entry 1: undisclosed foreign income, one row for each year60% of the gain
The same for FY 2025-26 (AY 2026-27)Usually a revised return instead, filed firstTax at the normal rate
A year in which the tax sales produced only small losses, and there was no other untaxed foreign incomeNothing in Entry 1; the shares still go in Entry 2—

Three points to settle before filing:

  1. Sold lots have a value. Rule 3(2) values each one at the higher of its cost and its sale price, converted at the reference rate on 31 March 2026. It is not nil, and it counts towards the ₹5 crore ceiling for Entry 2.
  2. Declare each year's net figure, as the better view. Undisclosed foreign income is income chargeable under the 1961 Act, so within a year a short-term loss on one sale sets off against a gain on another under section 70 (a long-term loss only against long-term gains). Name the sales in the row's description. Some advisers prefer to declare gross gains to be safe; the risk is that this overstates a particular that cannot be corrected afterwards. Settle the basis before filing. A capital loss cannot be set off against dividends or interest, which go in at their full amount.
  3. An unreported loss is a weaker point, not a nil one. A year whose only omission is a small loss has nothing to declare under Entry 1. Whether leaving it out of the return still counts as a failure to disclose foreign-source income for section 43 is arguable. Entry 2 covers the asset side of that year either way.

The order relative to any revised or updated return, and the comparison of routes, is in revised return, ITR-U or FAST-DS. If you had RSUs or an ESPP at an earlier employer too, see FAST-DS and an earlier employer's plan. The window closes on 31 December 2026: what has to happen by then.

Going forward

From tax year 2026-27 the Income-tax Act, 2025 applies, with equivalent provisions for the perquisite, the cost and the conversion, and a new return form. For each vest from now on:

  • Keep the release confirmation and the trade confirmation for the tax sale.
  • Put the tax sale in Schedule CG, with your employer's perquisite value as the cost.
  • Put the vested lot in the foreign assets schedule of the return, with the gross proceeds of the sale, for the period the new form asks for.
  • Check that the Form 16 perquisite matches the shares vested multiplied by the plan value and the rate payroll used. A vest payroll missed is salary for your return, not a FAST-DS item.

This note explains how sell-to-cover RSU vests are treated for Schedule CG, Schedule FA, the Black Money Act threshold and FAST-DS 2026. It is not advice on any individual's position. The figures in the illustration are invented. The cost rule is section 49(2AA) of the Income-tax Act, 1961; the conversion rule is Rule 115 of the Income-tax Rules, 1962; the valuation rule is Rule 3(2) of the FAST-DS Rules, 2026. From tax year 2026-27 the equivalent provisions of the Income-tax Act, 2025 apply. Whether a plan used sell-to-cover, and how a given year's sales should be treated, turns on the release and trade confirmations and the returns filed.

More guides in Foreign income, RSUs and ESOPs

All 32 guides in Foreign income, RSUs and ESOPs →

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between sell-to-cover and net settlement?

Under net settlement the employer keeps back enough shares to cover the tax and only the remaining shares are delivered to you, so the withheld shares were never yours. Under sell-to-cover the full number of vested shares is credited to your account and the broker then sells some of them, usually the next trading day, to pay the tax. The release confirmation shows which: it lists shares released, shares withheld or sold to cover, and shares deposited.

Do I have to report the sell-to-cover sale in my income tax return?

Yes, on the better view. The shares were credited to you and then sold, so the sale is a transfer by you and the difference between the sale proceeds and your cost is a capital gain or loss. Your cost is the value your employer took for the perquisite (section 49(2AA)), so the result is usually small, but it still belongs in Schedule CG. Because the rupee cost and the rupee sale value are converted on different dates, a sale at a small dollar loss can be a rupee gain.

Does a sell-to-cover sale go into Schedule FA?

Yes, on the better view, for the calendar year of the vest. Schedule FA covers holdings held at any time during the calendar year, including shares bought and sold within it; the table for foreign equity even has a column for the gross proceeds of a sale. The vested lot goes in with its acquisition date and value, and the sale proceeds go in that column. The brokerage account goes in its own table with its peak and closing balance.

I never reported the tax sales in past years. Is FAST-DS the fix?

For the shares, usually yes: shares received as taxed salary and left out of Schedule FA go in Entry 2 of the FAST-DS Table for a flat ₹1 lakh, sold shares included. For the gains, it depends on the year's result. If the year had a net capital gain from foreign shares that was never offered, that is undisclosed foreign income at 60% under Entry 1. If the tax sales produced only small losses and there was no other untaxed foreign income that year, such as dividends or interest, there is nothing to put in Entry 1 for that year, and whether the unreported loss itself leaves any exposure is arguable. For AY 2026-27, the current year, the gains belong in a revised return instead.

Does sell-to-cover matter for the ₹20 lakh Black Money Act threshold?

It can. CBDT's instruction of 18 August 2025 applies the prosecution threshold to the aggregate value of foreign assets at any time during the year, so for prosecution it works as a peak. On a vest day under sell-to-cover the account holds the full vested shares, and after the sale it holds the retained shares plus the sale proceeds until the tax is paid over. Counting only the net shares can understate the peak. For an employee who sells soon after every vest the peak usually stays well below ₹20 lakh, but a large vest, or a year of holding, can take it over.

My broker shows the tax sale under my employer's name, not mine. Is it still my sale?

Look at the trade confirmation. If the shares were credited to your account and the sale settled in your account before the tax was passed to the employer, it was your sale. Some confirmations describe the sale as made on the employer's instruction or label it 'for tax', which is a description of why, not of whose shares were sold. Where the plan genuinely withholds shares before delivery, it is net settlement and there is no sale by you.

Not sure whether your vests were sell-to-cover or net-settled?

Send one release confirmation from each year, or the plan's benefit history, and the returns filed for those years. Which method your plan used, whether the tax sales were reported and what that means for Schedule FA and FAST-DS are worked out from the documents.

Related service: Foreign Income / RSU & ESOP