CA K Sanjay BhargavChartered Accountant
Open menu

A Black Money Act section 43 penalty notice: how the reply is built

CA K Sanjay Bhargav, Chartered Accountant, Bengaluru

Membership No. 250054 · DISA (ICAI)

Published

Start here: what you are holding

A show-cause notice under section 46 of the Black Money (Undisclosed Foreign Income and Assets) and Imposition of Tax Act, 2015, asking why a penalty under section 43 should not be imposed for failing to report a foreign asset or foreign income in the return for a named assessment year.

Which route applies

  • Check the procedure first

    Who issued it, whether it names the year and the asset or income, whether it carries a DIN, and, once an order is passed, whether it was passed within a year from the end of the financial year of the notice and with Joint Commissioner approval where the law requires it.

  • Then test the ₹20 lakh threshold

    For returns from 1 October 2024 the penalty does not apply where the foreign assets, other than immovable property, did not exceed ₹20 lakh in aggregate. Whether that reaches earlier returns is arguable. It never covers unreported foreign income.

  • Then the discretion

    The section says the officer may direct a penalty, not that he must. Taxed money, income offered, an asset shown elsewhere in the return, a small value and a correction made before any enquiry are the facts that have persuaded the Tribunal to delete it.

  • An order has already been passed

    Appeal to the Commissioner (Appeals) within 30 days of service of the notice of demand. A late appeal can be admitted for sufficient cause only if the delay does not exceed one year.

What to send: The show-cause notice, the return for the year named (with Schedule FA and the foreign income schedules), and statements of the foreign asset for that year.

Send it and get the position

Routes and windows depend on the notice actually issued and the facts behind it. Confirm against the notice before relying on this.

Short answer: section 43 of the Black Money Act lets the officer levy ₹10 lakh for each year a foreign asset or foreign income was not reported, or was reported inaccurately, in a return, even where all the tax was paid. It is discretionary: the section says the officer "may direct". The penalty order must meet procedural conditions. And from 1 October 2024 it does not reach assets, other than immovable property, worth ₹20 lakh or less in aggregate. Build the reply in that order: procedure, threshold, discretion, then the fallback. An updated return does not remove the exposure. A FAST-DS declaration before 31 December 2026 may.

What section 43 says

The penalty applies to a person who:

  • was resident and ordinarily resident in India for the year;
  • furnished a return under section 139(1), 139(4) or 139(5) of the Income-tax Act (original, belated or revised); and
  • in that return failed to furnish any information, or furnished inaccurate particulars, about a foreign asset held at any time in the year (as owner, beneficial owner or beneficiary) or about income from a source outside India.

The officer "may direct" a penalty of ₹10 lakh. Four consequences:

  • It is per year. Five years of blank Schedule FA is five separate exposures.
  • It is a fixed sum. There is no smaller penalty for a smaller asset; the choice is between ₹10 lakh and nothing.
  • It does not depend on tax. A fully taxed RSU holding left out of Schedule FA is still a default. See the assets people forget to report.
  • It has two limbs. One is the asset; the other is foreign-source income. The thresholds below apply only to the first.

Where no return was filed by the end of the assessment year, the corresponding penalty is under section 42, also ₹10 lakh.

Layer 1: the procedure

The Act sets the procedure in section 46 and the limitation in section 47. Each is a ground on its own.

CheckProvisionWhat to look for
A show-cause notice was issueds.46(1)No penalty without one
You were heards.46(3)"No order ... shall be made unless the assessee has been given an opportunity of being heard"
Joint Commissioner's approvals.46(4)Required where the penalty exceeds ₹5 lakh and the officer is an Assistant or Deputy Commissioner (₹1 lakh for an Income-tax Officer). A ₹10 lakh order by an Income-tax Officer, Assistant or Deputy Commissioner always needs it
The order is in times.47(1)Not after one year from the end of the financial year in which the show-cause notice issued
A DIN on the notice and the orderCBDT Circular 19/2019A communication without one needs checking
The year, the asset or income, and the default are namedGeneral principlesA notice that does not say what was not reported is hard to answer and easier to challenge
You were ROR that years.43A non-resident or not-ordinarily-resident year is outside it
The return was under 139(1), (4) or (5)s.43No return at all is section 42, not 43

No time limit to start. Section 46(2) fixes when the show-cause must issue only for the penalties under sections 41 and 45. On the text, a section 43 notice can come for an old year. Some argue a reasonable time should be read in where the statute is silent; that is not settled.

Layer 2: the threshold

The proviso to section 43 has two versions:

ReturnsThe proviso
Up to 30 September 2024No penalty for "one or more bank accounts" with an aggregate balance up to ₹5 lakh at any time in the year. Shares, brokerage accounts and everything else had no threshold
From 1 October 2024No penalty for an "asset or assets (other than immovable property)" with an aggregate value up to ₹20 lakh

Three points to settle in the reply:

  • Which version applies. On one view, penalty law is the law in force when the default happened (Brij Mohan v CIT, Supreme Court), so a return filed before 1 October 2024 is judged on the old proviso. On the other, the section as it now stands carries the ₹20 lakh proviso, and the levy is discretionary anyway. Argue both where the facts allow.
  • How "aggregate value" is measured. CBDT's instruction of 18 August 2025, on prosecution, tests it "at any time during the relevant previous year", which is a peak. Compute the peak from daily values, counting shares and cash once. See the ₹20 lakh threshold.
  • Income is outside it. If the year also had unreported foreign dividends, interest or gains, the income limb stands whatever the asset value.

Layer 3: the discretion

"May direct" matters. The Tribunal has treated section 43 as discretionary, and has deleted the penalty where the default was technical and bona fide:

DecisionWhat it held
Vinil Venugopal (ITAT Mumbai, Special Bench, 2025)Section 43 is discretionary: "may" gives the officer a choice, and where two readings are possible the one favouring the assessee is taken. The appeals went back to the Division Bench for the merits
ACIT v Rohit Krishna (ITAT Mumbai, 2024)The Revenue's appeals were dismissed and the deletion upheld: the ESOP perquisite was taxed through TDS, the shares were shown in Schedule AL, and the omission from Schedule FA was bona fide. For two years, updated returns had added the shares to Schedule FA, which counted in the assessee's favour
Shobha Harish Thawani v JCIT (ITAT Mumbai, 2023)Penalty upheld: income from a foreign investment was offered, but the investment was left out of Schedule FA for three years. The Tribunal said the discretion was exercised judiciously, and also that section 43 left no room to drop the penalty where Schedule FA omitted the asset. The order predates the Special Bench

The facts that carry the discretion argument:

  • The source was explained and taxed: RSUs or ESPP shares taxed as salary, a bank account funded from declared income.
  • The income was offered, in the original return or a revision.
  • The asset appeared elsewhere in the return, such as Schedule AL.
  • The value was small, or the default was a misdescribed field rather than a missing asset.
  • It was corrected before any enquiry: a revised return under section 139(5), or a declaration.
  • A plausible misunderstanding: the general and long-standing confusion about calendar-year reporting, or a preparer's error. The return is the taxpayer's own, so a preparer's slip goes to good faith only, not to liability.

Hindustan Steel Ltd v State of Orissa (Supreme Court) is the general authority that a penalty should not be imposed for a technical or venial breach, or one arising from a bona fide belief.

What does not help

  • An updated return. Section 139(8A) is not one of the returns section 43 looks at, so the original omission stands. It is still evidence of good faith; Rohit Krishna is the example. See revised return, ITR-U or FAST-DS.
  • "No tax was lost." Section 43 penalises the reporting failure itself. It is a point on discretion, not a defence on liability.
  • Conceding more than the facts. Acknowledge what the return shows, explain why it happened with evidence, and do not call it deliberate. Do not volunteer other years or limbs that the notice does not raise.

Layer 4: the fallback

If the officer is not persuaded:

  • Year by year. Each year is a separate penalty. A year cured by a revised return under 139(5), a year below the threshold, a non-resident year: each drops out separately.
  • The asset limb only, or the income limb only. If the notice relies on one limb, answer that limb.
  • Appeal. To the Commissioner (Appeals) under section 15, within 30 days of service of the notice of demand. A late appeal can be admitted for sufficient cause if the delay is not more than one year. A further appeal lies to the Appellate Tribunal under section 18 within 60 days.

Where FAST-DS fits

Until 31 December 2026, an asset bought from taxed income and left out of Schedule FA can be declared under Entry 2 of the FAST-DS Table for a flat ₹1 lakh. Untaxed foreign income can be declared under Entry 1 at 60%. Section 139 of the Finance Act, 2026 grants immunity from "any further tax or penalty" under the Black Money Act "in respect of income or asset so declared".

The Scheme excludes only years with a completed Black Money Act assessment and proceeds of crime under pending money-laundering proceedings (section 140). A penalty show-cause is neither. On the text, a declaration is therefore still possible. Whether the immunity reaches a penalty proceeding already under way has not been decided. So decide on the declaration together with the reply, not after it. See what has to happen by 31 December.

Prosecution is separate

Section 50 makes a wilful failure to report a foreign asset or foreign income punishable with 6 months to 7 years of rigorous imprisonment. From 1 October 2024 it, too, does not apply to assets other than immovable property up to ₹20 lakh (a proviso inserted by the Finance Act, 2026). CBDT's instruction of 18 August 2025 says prosecution will not be started where the penalty is not imposed or imposable for that reason. Prosecution needs the sanction of the Principal Commissioner, Commissioner or Commissioner (Appeals) (section 55). A strong penalty reply is also the first line of defence against it.


This note explains section 43 of the Black Money (Undisclosed Foreign Income and Assets) and Imposition of Tax Act, 2015 and the reply to a show-cause under it. It is not advice on any individual's position. The procedure is from sections 46 and 47, the appeal from sections 15 and 18, and the thresholds from the provisos to sections 43 and 50 as amended; the Tribunal decisions are summarised on their own facts. A reply should be built on the return for the year, the statements of the asset and the notice itself, read together.

More guides in Tax notices and assessments

All 13 guides in Tax notices and assessments →

Frequently asked questions

What is the penalty under section 43 of the Black Money Act?

₹10 lakh for each previous year in which a resident and ordinarily resident person, who filed a return under section 139(1), 139(4) or 139(5) of the Income-tax Act, failed to report, or reported inaccurately, a foreign asset or foreign-source income held or earned at any time in that year. The section says the officer may direct the penalty, so it is discretionary. It is a fixed sum, not a percentage, and it does not depend on any tax having been lost.

My foreign assets were small. Does section 43 still apply?

For returns filed from 1 October 2024, the penalty does not apply in respect of assets other than immovable property whose aggregate value did not exceed ₹20 lakh. Before that, the only exception was for bank accounts with an aggregate balance up to ₹5 lakh, so shares and brokerage accounts had no threshold at all. Whether the ₹20 lakh limit helps a return filed before 1 October 2024 is arguable. And neither limit applies to unreported foreign income.

I filed an updated return (ITR-U) with the foreign income. Am I safe?

Not from section 43. The section looks at returns furnished under section 139(1), 139(4) or 139(5). An updated return under section 139(8A) is not among them, so the original return's omission stands. The updated return still helps on good faith: it shows the income was brought to tax voluntarily. The Tribunal has deleted the penalty in a case where updated returns had added the shares, but on the facts of that case.

Is there a time limit for the department to issue a section 43 notice?

The Act sets none for section 43. Section 46(2) fixes when the show-cause notice must issue only for the penalties under sections 41 and 45. What is fixed is the order: under section 47(1) it cannot be passed after one year from the end of the financial year in which the show-cause notice was issued. Some argue a reasonable time should be read in where the statute is silent; it is not settled.

Can I still use FAST-DS if I have a section 43 notice?

Possibly, until 31 December 2026. The Scheme excludes years with a completed Black Money Act assessment and proceeds of crime under money-laundering proceedings; a penalty show-cause is neither. An asset bought from taxed income and left out of Schedule FA can be declared for a flat ₹1 lakh, and the Scheme grants immunity from penalty for what is declared. Whether that immunity reaches a penalty proceeding already started is not settled, so the declaration and the reply have to be planned together.

How do I appeal a section 43 penalty order?

To the Commissioner (Appeals) under section 15 of the Black Money Act, within 30 days from the date the notice of demand for the penalty is served. The Commissioner (Appeals) may admit a late appeal for sufficient cause, but only if the delay is not more than one year. A further appeal lies to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal under section 18, within 60 days of the order being communicated.

Received a section 43 penalty notice?

Send the notice and the return for the year it names. Reading it costs nothing. Whether the notice is valid, whether the threshold applies and which facts carry the discretion argument are worked out before a reply is drafted.

Related service: Tax Notices & Assessments