Short answer: a section 148A show-cause about foreign income is now one of the commonest uses of the foreign account data India receives. Under the reopening rules recast from 1 September 2024, the section 148A show-cause must issue within 3 years from the end of the assessment year (5 years where escaped income is ₹50 lakh or more), and the section 148 notice within 3 years 3 months (5 years 3 months). There is no extension for the time allowed to reply. The first defences are specific to foreign income: whether you were resident that year, and whether the income was already offered under another head. The Black Money Act has no time limit to start, so a time-barred income-tax year is not a closed matter for an unexplained asset. Until 31 December 2026, FAST-DS may be the cheaper way to settle untaxed foreign income, and it alone gives Black Money Act immunity; price both.
Which years are still open
For AY 2026-27 and earlier, reassessment runs under the 1961 Act (sections 147 to 151), as saved by the Income-tax Act, 2025. The section 148A show-cause, with an opportunity to reply, must come before any section 148 notice, except where the information came under the scheme notified under section 135A (the e-verification scheme): then there is no show-cause, only the section 148 date applies, and the notice needs prior approval (section 148A(4)). Counting from the end of each assessment year, the last dates are:
| Assessment year | Under ₹50 lakh: 148A show-cause by | Under ₹50 lakh: 148 notice by | ₹50 lakh or more: 148A show-cause by | ₹50 lakh or more: 148 notice by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AY 2026-27 | 31 March 2030 | 30 June 2030 | 31 March 2032 | 30 June 2032 |
| AY 2025-26 | 31 March 2029 | 30 June 2029 | 31 March 2031 | 30 June 2031 |
| AY 2024-25 | 31 March 2028 | 30 June 2028 | 31 March 2030 | 30 June 2030 |
| AY 2023-24 | 31 March 2027 | 30 June 2027 | 31 March 2029 | 30 June 2029 |
| AY 2022-23 | Closed (31 March 2026) | Closed (30 June 2026) | 31 March 2028 | 30 June 2028 |
| AY 2021-22 | Closed | Closed | 31 March 2027 | 30 June 2027 |
| AY 2020-21 and earlier | Closed | Closed | Closed | Closed |
Test the show-cause date first. A show-cause for AY 2023-24 issued in April 2027 (escaped income under ₹50 lakh) is out of time even though the column for the notice runs to June. The substituted section 149 has no extension for the time allowed to reply or for a court stay: the three months between the two dates is the whole margin. So for AY 2022-23 (escaped income under ₹50 lakh) the show-cause had to issue by 31 March 2026 and the notice by 30 June 2026; a notice after that is out of time.
Searches, requisitions and surveys between 1 April 2021 and 31 August 2024, and cases where a section 148 notice or a section 148A(d) order came before 1 September 2024, stay under the earlier version of the law (section 152(3) and (4)). Check which version governs before counting.
Two points decide many cases before the merits:
- The ₹50 lakh foundation. For the show-cause in the longer period, the test is escaped income that "amounts to or is likely to amount to" ₹50 lakh or more "as per the information with the Assessing Officer". For the section 148 notice in the longer period, the officer must also hold books of account or other documents or evidence relating to an asset, expenditure, transaction or entries showing it. A notice that asserts the figure without that material is open to challenge, and this is where the jurisdiction argument is strongest.
- Sanction. For notices from 1 September 2024, section 151 names the Additional or Joint Commissioner, or the Additional or Joint Director, as the approving authority. Check the approval is from that authority, and that there is one. Since the Finance Act, 2026 (section 292BC, deemed from 1 April 2021), an approval is treated as administrative and cannot be attacked for brief reasons or defects of form, authentication or digital signature, so the argument now is the wrong authority or no approval at all.
The general rules are in section 148 reassessment: time limits and defences.
The defences specific to foreign income
Residential status
Foreign income received abroad is taxable in India only in the hands of a resident and ordinarily resident person, and, for a not-ordinarily-resident person, where it comes from a business controlled in or a profession set up in India (section 5). Income received in India is taxable whatever the status.
| Status that year | Foreign income taxable? |
|---|---|
| Non-resident | No, unless received in India |
| Resident but not ordinarily resident | No, unless received in India or derived from a business controlled in, or a profession set up in, India |
| Resident and ordinarily resident | Yes |
The department's data does not know your status. Establish it from your days in India in that year and the earlier years, proved by passport pages or the immigration record of entries and exits. A year abroad on deputation, the year you left, the years after you came back: each needs its own count. See the RNOR window.
Already offered, under another name
Foreign figures often reach a return without the label the department expects:
- RSU and ESPP perquisites are salary, taxed through payroll and in Form 16. A foreign broker's report of shares "received" is not new income.
- Sale proceeds are not income. Only the gain is, and the cost of RSU shares is the value taxed as salary (section 49(2AA)). A large gross proceeds figure in the data can mean a small gain, or a loss.
- Gains and dividends may sit under another head, such as Schedule CG "other assets" or Schedule OS, converted at a different rate.
- The data runs by calendar year; Indian returns run April to March. A January to March credit belongs to the return for the financial year ending that 31 March, which is the year before the return whose Schedule FA reports that calendar year.
Match each figure in the information to the return, line by line, before accepting that anything escaped.
Computation, if something did escape
- Conversion follows the Income-tax Rules: the gain is converted at the SBI telegraphic transfer buying rate on the last day of the month before the month of sale (Rule 115). In practice the sale price is converted at that rate, and the cost of RSU shares is the rupee value taxed as salary.
- Foreign tax credit under section 90 and the treaty is claimed with Form 67. Raise it in the reassessment, not afterwards.
- Interest and penalty. A reassessment carries interest, and a penalty under section 270A of 50% of the tax on under-reported income, or 200% where it is held to be misreporting. Section 270AA, as substituted by the Finance Act, 2026, gives immunity from the penalty where the tax and interest are paid and no appeal is filed; for misreporting it allows additional tax of 100% in place of the 200% penalty.